Why people love it
  • Lasts all day
  • Easy to apply, even for liquid liner novices
  • Marker-style tip
Cons

Some reviewers complain that this liquid liner dries out quickly, so make sure you put the lid on as soon as you’re done with your makeup.

Details

Formula: Liquid liner is a must if you want a dramatic look or deep, dark lines, and this formula is pigmented enough to let you achieve both of those goals. The rich hues and glossy sheen of this waterproof liner make it ideal for a romantic evening with your significant other or a fun-filled girls’ night out.

The ingredients aren’t as natural as the ones in the Antonym Certified Natural Waterproof Eye Pencil or the Tarte Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner, but they get the job done.

Performance: The stila Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner has been racking up the accolades for years (here’s a review from 2010 that proves it!). Makeup junkies love the smudge-proof, run-proof formula, and multiple reviewers dub it their “go-to eyeliner.” Did we mention it lasts all day?

Ease of Use: Mastering liquid liner can be tricky, but stila’s marker-like tip makes application a breeze. We’ve read numerous reviews that say this is the best liquid liner for newbies, and we totally agree! It travels smoothly across your lids, and that’s super important with liquid liner because it’s less forgiving than pencil.

Price: For around $22, you can confidently - and possibly even flawlessly - apply liquid liner with this easy-to-use product. Sounds like a good deal to us!

Featured in

Faveable Giveaway

$100 Amazon Gift Card


Amazon Gift Card

Join the conversation: stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Never make a dumb purchase again

Our tips in your mailbox: