Why people love it
  • Perfectly firm
  • Comfortable
  • Great mattress for the price

It doesn’t have a separate toddler side of the mattress. And a few users have reported that their mattresses are closer to 49” than 52.5”.


If you’re wondering how a crib mattress that retails for $60 can find itself competing with those that sell for $100-200, you’re not alone. We’ve been surprised by the way this budget crib mattress competes with the big boys. It meets all the requirements you would expect (lead-free, fire-safe, and more), but it does it at a fraction of the price.

How? Well it does appear that there may be a slight problem with quality control. A few users report their mattress being too short (which is a safety concern), and yet others have reported a smell indicating mold (a serious health concern). But, when it’s right, you’ve just scored a mattress that will make it through the toddler bed at a fantastic price. You will need to double check your mattress as soon as you receive it; take responsibility early on and you should be golden.

What’s it made of? It’s a thermo-bonded fiber foam covered with vinyl. That outer layer makes it resistant to smells and stains. The cover has a zip in case you want to remove it for washing, but it is waterproof so you may not need that.

What are the best features? It meets the federal flammability standards without additional, harmful chemicals. It’s also GREENGUARD GOLD certified. And then there’s the price.

Will it fit the crib? Okay, this is where you need to be a little careful. Though it should measure 52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5”, a few users have reported their crib mattress to be a little smaller. That’s not across the board; just some. But, you will need to be a little careful.

How should you care for it? A wipe-down should be all you need, but you can remove the cover if you really feel the need.

Are there any certifications, warranties, or awards? We like the GREENGUARD GOLD certification. That’s a big deal. But, you shouldn’t expect a lot more from a crib mattress at this price point.

Will it break the bank? The MSRP is $66, and you should find it on Amazon for a few dollars less. That makes this the least expensive crib mattress on our list. And, it’s really not a bad mattress for the price. It’s safe and easy to maintain. You may find yourself wondering why you should pay more.

Featured in

Faveable Giveaway

$100 Amazon Gift Card

Amazon Gift Card

Join the conversation: Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Never make a dumb purchase again

Our tips in your mailbox: