Peanut Butter and Jelly Set

Best Halloween Costume for Couples

Why people love it
  • Great costume for couples
  • Fun, easy to wear, and (surprisingly) comfortable
  • Super cute

You'll definitely need to wear something underneath this costume as the material can be uncomfortable on the skin. 


Let's be honest, sometimes it's just easier and cheaper to pick up a matching costume than spend hours laboring over what you'll wear to that party. If you find yourself in a jam (bad pun intended), then you could do a lot worse than this classic sandwich pairing. Of course, you run the risk of inappropriate questions about being in a sandwich of the two of you - but that depends on your friends, not the costume. 

Rating out of five:

  • Originality: 4
  • Scare Factor: 1
  • Sexy Factor: 2
  • Identifiable: 4

What’s it made of? The body of this is, as you would expect, made of 100 percent polyester. Each slice of bread has a foam insert to keep the shape. And yes, there are two different slices of toast. 

Will you need extra bits? Not a thing. Isn't that nice? Okay, if you and your partner can't find tops and pants of the same color, you may need to sort that out. We're guessing that the chances of that are slim.

Is it hand wash only? Yes. And you'll want to remove the outer tunic to wash this costume.

Will it break the bank? No! You get both peanut butter and jelly for less than $30. That's $15 a person. If you're on a budget, this could be the costume for you. 

Faveable Giveaway

$100 Amazon Gift Card

Amazon Gift Card

Join the conversation: Peanut Butter and Jelly Set

Never make a dumb purchase again

Our tips in your mailbox: