David's 2-lb. Cookie Tin

Best Gift for the Girlfriend With a Sweet Tooth

Why people love it
  • Homemade taste
  • Soft texture
  • Variety of flavors

Shipped the same day they’re baked for a fresh, made-from-scratch taste. Kosher certified.

A few reviewers complain the cookies tasted dry or stale, but we noticed most of these complaints came from eBay purchases. The majority of folks who buy this gift tin through Amazon are happy with it.


Details: Chocolate-covered strawberries and cherries are delicious, but she’s probably received plenty of those over the years. Switch things up and satisfy her sweet tooth with 6 different cookie flavors, including classics like chocolate chunk, oatmeal raisin, and peanut butter, as well as unique flavors like cherry with white chocolate chips.

These cookies are made from real butter and contain no added preservatives. All 6 varieties in this tin contain wheat, but the company does offer some gluten-free options as well.

Price: Expect to shell out around $34 for 24 cookies. Yeah, you could buy 6 or 7 packs of Chips Ahoy for that price, but trust us when we say they’re nowhere near as tasty as David’s Cookies.

Faveable Giveaway: $100 Amazon Gift Card

Amazon Gift Card

Join the conversation: David's 2-lb. Cookie Tin

Never make a dumb purchase again

Our tips in your mailbox: