6 Best Scar Removal Creams

6 Best Scar Removal Creams

18
Hours
Researched
42
Products
Evaluated

After 18 hours of research evaluating 42 products, we picked Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream as our top choice.

Stuck with stretch marks? Wondering how to get rid of acne scars?

Believe it or not, scar removal cream treatments and silicone gels can actually do a great job at reducing the appearance of scars as well as softening and flattening them.

Now, these products won’t work overnight; there is no magic wand when it comes to scars new or old, big or small. You will need to give any scar removal cream time to work, but each one of these has seemingly worked miracles for real users at some point.

While it’s almost impossible to remove scars, especially without laser, steroid, radiography, or dermabrasion treatment of some sort, these products do the job of making scars appear much smaller – sometimes almost invisible.

That’s good news, right?

As you would expect, however, the older the scar, the longer it will take. So, what’s stopping you from picking up an awesome cream for your burn or surgery scars, stretch marks, or the best acne scar treatment you can find?

The faster you get started, the better those scars will look in a few months or even weeks.

Why trust us: Faveable has spent thousands of hours researching, interviewing experts, and testing products to come up with carefully selected lists trusted by millions of consumers since 2013.

6 Best Scar Removal Creams

  • 6. Stretch Marks and Scar Defense Cream
  • 5. Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel
  • 4. Mederma Scar Cream Plus SPF 30
  • 3. Bio-Oil Liquid Purcellin Oil
  • 2. ScarAway 100% Silicon Self-Drying Scar Repair Gel
  • 1. Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream

Best Scar Removal Cream for Stretch Marks

#6

Stretch Marks and Scar Defense Cream

Best Scar Removal Cream for Stretch Marks: Stretch Marks and Scar Defense Cream
76 % Editor Score
82 % User Score
314 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Perfect for stretch marks
  • Lightens and diminishes even old scars
  • Amazing texture and soft skin

The 90-day guarantee is serious business; the company even checks in to ensure you’re enjoying the product. It’s also wonderfully hydrating and cost-effective.

This isn’t an overall scar removal cream.

You’re forgiven if you believed this to be just a pregnancy or weight-related stretch mark cream. It’s so much more than that. Many users have found amazing success with this product when it comes to old scars and stretch marks. It does the job of lightening and reducing the appearance of scars as well as softening the skin to flatten marks.

Now, there are those that just can’t stand the smell of this product, though the number is reasonably balanced against those that do enjoy it. And, you’ll be pleased to know the company will refund your money even if smell is the reason you don’t end up loving it. But, it’s the second-to-none texture of this cream and the ultra-quick absorption that really turned our heads. Overall, it’s worth a shot whether your stretch mark scars are new or old.

Consistency: Thick, body butter-like cream

Scent: Light cocoa scent with an undertone of oranges

Notable ingredients: There’s a mix of ultra-hydrating ingredients such as oils, plant extracts and butters along with vitamins E, C, B3, and B5. Basically, it’s food for your skin.

Parabens: No

Cruelty-free: Yes

Application: You’re supposed to use it twice daily, rubbing it into the affected areas when using it as a scar removal option or all over if you’re hoping to prevent stretch marks.

Package options: There’s a 4-ounce tub available.

Cost: You’ll pay about $20 for the 4 ounces, working out to $5 per ounce which is on the very reasonable side as far as scar removal creams go.

Best Scar Removal Gel for Acne

#5

Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel

Best Scar Removal Gel for Acne: Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel
82 % Editor Score
85 % User Score
396 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Great for surgery scars
  • Works wonders on facial and acne scars
  • Reduces redness and lightens scars

This is one of the most professionally-recommended products. It does a stunning job on facial and acne scars, lightening and flattening both new and old wounds.

It’s super expensive – and you need to give it some time to work; not everyone is that patient. 

Acne scars are the most difficult to make disappear. If you have them, you’ve probably tried a range of options – and probably spent a small fortune. Luckily, you’ve just stumbled on the best acne scar treatment available. It also does an amazing job reducing the appearance and size of facial surgery scars. (In case you’re wondering, once it dries, it doesn’t mess with any makeup you’d want to apply over it.)

We know this is expensive, but it really is the best acne scar treatment option that you can buy over-the-counter and you want to try it before you opt for surgery. But, we do want to let you know that you shouldn’t expect speedy results. You will achieve visible results, but it does take some time. Indeed, despite the price, we would suggest that you buy the 2-pack straight away in order to give it your best foot forward.

Consistency: It’s a clear gel which can take some time to absorb into the skin.

Scent: There’s a neutral scent that doesn’t seem to offend many (if any) people.

Notable ingredients: 100% silicone, including polysiloxanes and silicone dioxide,

Parabens: No

Cruelty-free: Yes

Application: You’re meant to apply it twice daily. We think you may want to consider early morning and late afternoon rather than applying it before bed as it does take some time to absorb.

Package options: It’s a tiny .35-oz (10 gram) tube.

Cost: Yes, this is wildly expensive when you break it down into price per ounce (it’s roughly $75 per ounce), but most users find that a tiny amount goes a long, long way, so it should last you quite some time. There aren’t any Subscribe and Save options at the moment, but there are different pack sizes (1, 2, 6) so you can save a couple bucks if you’re invested for the long term. The single pack size usually goes for about $5 less than the $32 MSRP.

Best Scar Removal Cream with SPF

#4

Mederma Scar Cream Plus SPF 30

Best Scar Removal Cream with SPF: Mederma Scar Cream Plus SPF 30
80 % Editor Score
88 % User Score
332 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Lightens appearance of scars
  • Excellent for surgery scars
  • Really works (sometimes with time and sometimes quickly)

The small tube size allows you to easily pack this into your purse. The SPF is a bonus and the product has a pleasant smell.

There are those that experience breakouts when using this and it does take some time to work.

There’s no discounting the brand behind this product and this particular scar removal cream is no exception. We appreciate its ability to protect against further damage while it lightens and reduces the appearance of scars. That makes it a viable option for visible scars (think facial issues) – and it doesn’t do a bad job with acne scars either. That said, it does tend to do a fantastic job with surgery scars.

The manufacturer believes it should take about 8 weeks to be effective on new scars, and it could take as much as 6 months for older scars. But, there are plenty of users that have found success faster. One thing most of the successful users have found is that it’s important to follow the usage instructions – which means applying it 3 times a day.

Consistency: The texture of this cream is excellent – and non-oily. It also absorbs quickly.

Scent: This scar removal cream doesn’t smell bad at all. Most users find this mostly unscented product rather pleasant smelling.

Notable ingredients: Avobezone 3%, Octorcrylene 10%, and Oxybenone 6% - along with Cepalin.

Parabens: Yes

Cruelty-free: Unfortunately, no.

Application: It should be applied evenly and massaged into the scar 3 times daily until absorbed.

Package options: 0.6 oz (20 grams)

Cost: You should expect to pay between $15-17 for this scar cream with SPF when you order it on Amazon. There’s also a Subscribe and Save option which will save you more. However, this product is still one of the more expensive options when you break it down to price per ounce (roughly $27 per ounce).

Best Budget Scar Removal Oil

#3

Bio-Oil Liquid Purcellin Oil

Best Budget Scar Removal Oil: Bio-Oil Liquid Purcellin Oil
86 % Editor Score
89 % User Score
261 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Good for stretch marks
  • Smells fantastic
  • Definitely lightens scars

This vegan scar removal oil is cost-effective, smells delicious, and has won 224 skincare awards. It’s particularly good for stretch marks and reduces their appearance dramatically.

Besides the varying levels of efficacy, there really aren’t any, except this product is sold in China which means it is tested on animals.

Not everyone loves an oil formula when it comes to scar removal, but it is highly effective, providing the skin with a load of benefits. You do, however, have to spend some time working it in to avoid grease stains on your clothing. That said, your skin will love it and almost everyone finds its scent intoxicatingly good.

We do love that it’s vegan, but we take some issue with the fact that it’s sold in China (meaning Bio-Oil is tested on animals). If you can get over that, this is the sort of product that you want to have on hand for emergencies – and during and after pregnancy as it is surprisingly effective on stretch marks as well. It doesn’t hurt that it’s one of the most cost-effective scar removal products on the market… and that it’s wonderfully effective.

Consistency: Translucent oil

Scent: It’s unscented, but it has a sort of earthy aroma that users love.

Notable ingredients: Inside, you’ll find a pile of vitamins and essential oils including vitamin A to promote collagen development and elasticity.

Parabens: No

Cruelty-free: This is a bit of a tricky one. You see, Bio-Oil complies with the Beauty without Cruelty law in the UK which states that any product manufactured in England must not be tested on animals. But, it is sold in China, which means that the final product must be tested on animals before it can be sold in that market. What a shame.

Application: It’s meant to be rubbed into the affected area in a circular motion. The manufacturers suggest using it twice a day every day for at least 3 months to see results.

Package options: There are a couple of different product sizes available, including a 2-ounce (great for travel), a 4.2-ounce bottle, and a 6-ounce bottle. The larger sizes are available for Prime shipping and all 3 qualify for the Subscribe and Save program.

Cost: The 4.2-ounce bottle costs somewhere between $12-13, meaning that you’ll spend roughly $3 per ounce – a little more if it pushes up towards $13 and a little less if you put it on your Subscribe and Save list.

Best Scar Removal Product to Splurge on

#2

ScarAway 100% Silicon Self-Drying Scar Repair Gel

Best Scar Removal Product to Splurge on: ScarAway 100% Silicon Self-Drying Scar Repair Gel
76 % Editor Score
93 % User Score
459 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Good for new surgery scars
  • Flattens scars and softens skin
  • Scars become almost invisible

This FDA-1 medical treatment is effective at flattening scars and is discreet to use anywhere – especially on facial scars.

In addition to the price, there are more than a few users that report it taking too long to dry.

Okay, not everyone can afford this scar removal gel, but if you can, it’s a terrific way to go. It’s really effective at flattening and reducing the irritation of scars. It’s most effective for surgery scars and is frequently recommended by healthcare professionals for skin cancer wounds. But, it should absolutely be used twice a day to ensure it does the job it should do.

When it comes to application, it’s a little touch and go. There are some users that experience a rapid-drying product, but there are a few that find it dries too slowly (or never quite absorbs completely). Humidity may have something to do with it, so it’s best not to put it on in a steamy bathroom. And, while you need to give it a few months before scars will start appearing invisible, some users and wounds disappear much faster.

Consistency: It’s a transparent (usually fast-drying) liquid gel that absorbs quickly.

Scent: It’s supposed to be odorless. If you receive a product that smells strongly (perhaps a little like nail polish), then you should get in touch with the manufacturer.

Notable ingredients: Polysiloxanes and silicon dioxide, which many surgical pharmacists recommend.

Parabens: No

Cruelty-free: Unknown

Application: Brush onto scars twice daily. It can be sticky at first, but it should dry quickly. If it doesn’t, then you may have applied too much; just dab it with a paper towel.

Package options: 0.71 oz

Cost: It’s around $40 for a single tube. Amazon does offer a 2-pack which will save you a few bucks, and there is also a Subscribe and Save option. All the same, it does cost something like $55 per ounce. It’s expensive, but it gets the job done.

Best Scar Removal Cream Overall

#1

Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream

Best Scar Removal Cream Overall: Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream
76 % Editor Score
96 % User Score
1,249 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Highly effective
  • Works faster than expected
  • Great for new scars, especially surgical scars

This well-priced scar removal cream does an amazing job on surgery, as well as burn, scars. It’s for night use so your body can make the most of the healing ingredients.

The directions for use aren’t terribly clear. (Please take a look at our notes.)

Mederma is one of the best-known scar removal brands and this particular formulation is no different. Some lucky users experience results in as little as two weeks, but it all depends on the type of scar – and how old it is. The manufacturers suggest remaining patient for four months.

While this does a decent job with acne scars, it really shines with surgery and burn scars. The fresher the wounds, the better it will do. As with any scar removal product, not everyone experiences the same dramatic results. But, you’re supposed to apply it at night which means you can use it in tandem with other Mederma products to accelerate healing. Given all of that, we think it’s worth a try.

Consistency: It’s a white cream that absorbs into the skin.

Scent: Pleasant, light, almost neutral scent.

Notable ingredients: Tripeptol (a combination of collagen, peptides, and antioxidants) as well as Dimethicone (2%).

Parabens: No

Cruelty-free: Sadly, no.

Application: Nightly application. Apply only to the scar itself and that’s it. Don’t rub it in more than needed and don’t let it work into the surrounding area.

Package options: 1 oz. tube

Cost: The MSRP puts this scar removal cream just over $15, but you should get it for a little less than that if you put it on your Subscribe and Save list. That makes it around $15 per ounce which makes this one of the most reasonably-priced scar removal products available.

Faveable Expert Tips

SCAR REMOVAL CREAM BUYING GUIDE 

Your skin is a fragile organ, like silk, and can be damaged easily. Scars may appear on the surface of your skin, due to acne or surgery. However, not everyone can proudly pose with scars.

Celebrities like Kylie Jenner — Travis Scott’s gorgeous wife — lately posed on the cover of GQ magazine with her apparent scar on the left leg. The “Grown-ish” star Francia Raisa gave one of her kidney to her friend Selena Gomez, and mentioned, showing her scar, she was “happy to be back” after her surgery. 

The truth is, scars are part of you. They bear your identity and if you embrace them, there are less reasons to hide them. If you want to remove or hide your scars, there are only two ways to go: surgery or a scar removal cream.

So which creams can you choose to hide scars? What causes scars to appear and how can you treat them? Remember that first, deciding to treat your scar or leave it alone can only result from a diagnosis and medical advice. Second, if you decide to leave your scar alone and use creams, follow this guide. 

What is scarring? 

A scar is defined as an area of fibrous tissue that appears on the skin after an injury. When the dermis — the deeper level of the skin — is damaged (burned, injured, or after an operation), a scar forms.

Scarring is a biological process that results from the skin repairing itself. A research paper from 2003 states that each year in developed countries, over 100 million people get a scar. Three-quarter of patients get a scar following a surgery or an injury. The half is due to elective surgery i.e. surgery planned in advance and a quarter result from operations after trauma. 

Any wound that is caused to the skin should get total rejuvenation — yet scarring is inevitable and often the final result as the skin does not 100% rejuvenate. Some scars may be aesthetically unpleasant and may require surgery. Yet most skin scars are pale and flat.

When the skin is injured, it creates collagen to repair the wound. Collagen is a protein that is produced by the skin naturally. If collagen production is increasing, scars may become larger and inflated. 

How to prevent scarring:

Scars are likely to stay permanent. The best treatment is actually to prevent scarring. For example, if you are wounded, don’t let the wounds dry. Consult a doctor and take care of your wound.

Apply antiseptic or any antibacterial ointment and skin-rejuvenation products. Never scratch your skin or touch the wound unless totally recovered. If the wound is large, visit a dermatologist or skin doctor within the next 24 hours to receive proper care. If your wound doesn’t heal well, take another appointment with the doctor. 

Different types of scars 

Acne scars: The overproduction of acne can cause the appearance of atrophic scars. Such scars look flat and depressed surrounding the skin. Acne scarring is common in teens and may be treated according to dermatologist advice. To prevent acne scars, cleanse your skin accordingly and ensure to use the right toners and antibacterial day creams. A chemical peel may be used too. 

Contracture scars: Burn scars are the least widespread type of scarring. After a second or third degree burn, contracture scars may appear, causing the skin to look damaged. Their appearance is hypertrophic with enlarged skin tissue. The skin is thicker and these scars can even go deeper, affecting muscles. Post-burn scars may require plastic surgery. 

Keloid scars: These scars are raised beyond the surface of the skin and result from an aggressive healing process. Keloid scars can be treated with silicon-based treatment or surgery (excision). Oil treatment may also help reduce inflammation. Uncomfortable, keloid scars can cause pain, tenderness or feel itchy from time to time. Growing slowly, they can take time to appear. 

Stretch scars: Also known as widespread scars, these scars often appear three weeks following surgery. These scars are symptomless, pale and soft; they are unlikely to thicken. Stretch marks may also result from pregnancy when the abdominal part of the skin enlarges. When the skin is weakened, a stretched scar can appear like a protection to the broadened areas of the skin. 

The best treatments for scars 

Always consult a dermatologist to identify the best treatments for your scars. Do not undergo surgery without having without a medical diagnosis. If for any reason, scars happen on your skin, call a doctor and check what are the causes and treatments available for your types of scars. 

Here are the most common scar treatments:

Scar removal creams and top ingredients to treat scars

Scar removal creams that contain vitamin E, cocoa butter, and a variety of skincare products may help your scar heal and the skin rejuvenate quicker. Choose clinically proven creams that may reduce scars. Silicon-based products are said to be the most effective but other ingredients such as salicylic acid or retinol are great at speeding up skin recovery. 

Bio-oil — a miracle product for small scars or skin problems — is one of the most effective oils that boost skin recovery. Yet bio-oil should not be applied to open wounds. A popular oil, this miracle treatment contains the breakthrough ingredient PurCellin Oil™ which is made of plant-based oils and vitamins. Branded as the world’s most famous product to treat scars, bio-oil also prevents skin aging. Also perfect for dehydrated skin, bio-oil provides nutrients and vitamins to rehydrate the skin quickly. 

Rosehip seed oil is another promising skin scar treatment. Plus, rosehip seed oil is also good to prevent and treat acne. Packed with skin-nourishing vitamins, rosehip seed oil is pressed from the rose plant and is a natural antioxidant. Full of vitamin C, rosehip has a high amount of linoleic acid which are fatty-acids. This oil has a combination of plants extracts and vitamins that are highly sought-after for the skin. 

Vitamin A in the form of retinol is also great at boosting the skins natural healing process. In the cosmetic industry, retinol is known as an anti-aging product with multiple benefits. Retinol prevents wrinkles to appear, brightens dull, pale skin, treats acne and furthermore, helps remove dark spots onthe skin. Although retinol has great benefits, the main drawback is it’s made from animal oil, which, for vegans like me, makes it a no-go scar treatment. 

Dermabrasion, laser, and surgery

Dermabrasion is a skin-resurfacing procedure that may be useful when treating scars. This procedure is perfect to improve the overall look of scars. Using a machine that goes on the surface of the skin, dermabrasion softens the skin, removes dead cells, and enhances the skins appearance, and uneven skin tone. It can remove scars caused by acne, injuries, and surgeries. 

Laser resurfacing can be necessary when there’s no other possibility to treat the skin “naturally” or in the case of contracture or post-injury scars. These types of lasers achieve subtle results working on the collagen in the dermis without removing the upper layers of the skin. The recovery is quicker for this type of procedure. 

Plastic surgery can become an option for severe skin scars. Although it won’t remove the scar fully, it can make its appearance look nicer. This surgery is not recommended in the case of contracture or keloid scars which may boost the appearance of new scars. Always consult a dermatologist or plastic surgeon to get the right advice before undergoing this surgery. 

What you need to know about acne and scarring

Acne is a condition that may damage the skin and, if untreated well, can cause severe damage. Created by the overproduction of sebum that makes pimples appearing on the skin, acne can be treated, leaving the skin healthy. Remember that, on top of it, getting the right nutrition can prevent skin problems. For example, avoid sugar or greasy foods in general for good health. Second, stress or sleep deprivation may create imbalance and skin problems like acne, as well as hormonal imbalance. 

When acne and scarring work in pair, follow a daily routine to treat your skin accordingly. Choose a cleanser and toner that contains salicylic acid which is a good ingredient for congested follicles and blemishes skin.

Don’t dry the skin with an astringent as it may cause more damage in the long-run and don’t over hydrate the skin which may make it more greasy. Go for a lightweight moisturizer that will gently hydrate the surface of the skin without making it oily.

To remove the whiteheads, apply a cleanser that contains Benzoyl Peroxide, an antibacterial ingredient which is used to treat mild to moderate acne. For the persistent, deeper type of acne, consult a dermatologist who may prescribe medication. 

A final recommendation for treating acne:

  • Don’t pop blemishes or whiteheads as you may create a scar  
  • Always clean your hands before touching the face of your skin
  • Drink enough water to stay hydrated and prevent the skin from drying
  • Always consult a doctor to get the best acne treatment for your skin type
  • Use a facial mask twice a week to deepen the daily treatment and get rid of blemishes, whiteheads, and cleanse your face overall. 

Home remedies to remove — or flatten — scars

Some natural, miraculous products or ingredients may be used to treat scars and help the skin rejuvenate quicker. 

Vitamin E: A favorite vitamin for the skin, vitamin E has great benefits and helps the skin heal better. Cut off a vitamin E capsule, extract the oil, and apply gently onto the skin. 

Fish oil/fatty acids:Fish oil contains two types of omega 3 acids which can help regulate oil production to boost hydration as well delay the skin aging process and diminish wrinkles. Omega 3 acids also prevent acne. 

Honey: Thanks to its deep healing properties, honey truly soothes the skin. Honey is said to help decrease scar formation and leave the skin softer. 

Aloe Vera: A fantastic healing plant, aloe vera gel helps the skin rejuvenate and remove scars gently. By providing deep, lasting hydration to the skin, aloe vera components heal the skin in the long run. If you can’t find pure aloe vera, simply purchase aloe vera gel available over-the-counter in most shops or pharmacies.

Coconut oil: Another miraculous, natural ingredient, coconut oil has numerous benefits. Highly rich, coconut oil creates a protective barrier onto the skin while providing intense hydration and promotes deep skin healing thanks to the vitamins it contains. Lastly, coconut oil boosts collagen production helping the skin recover from scars and marks. 

Lavender oil: This oil is great for skin repair. A powerful antiseptic and antioxidant, lavender oil promotes tissue growth which may help the scar to heal. It’s a natural ingredient that is proven to heal deep wounds. 

Potato: The raw potato is an excellent ingredient to treat acne and acne scars. Containing potassium, phosphorus, and sulfur, raw potato is one of the best home remedies to treat scars. Simply cut off the potato and apply it fresh onto the damaged area. 

 

We value your feedback

What did you think of 6 Best Scar Removal Creams?
6 Best Scar Removal Creams
4.66 Stars (16 Votes)

Vote to enter our $100 Amazon Gift Card giveaway.

Article Staff

Katie’s Cleveland proud; but she’s also lived in Australia, Switzerland and now stays in South Africa. That’s a roundabout way of saying she can’t sit still; she’s always moving, always busy.

She has a BA in International Relations from Kent State University and work towards a Masters in Human Rights. She speaks French, is learning German and used to dream in Spanish. For years, Katie worked as a producer on fashion and advertising shoots before she realized her passion was the written word.

Katie’s far more interested in guy’s gear than women’s, except she has a wardrobe brimming with little black dresses. She drinks her beer out of the bottle and is raising her two boys to be better men.

Editor Jenna Holtz
Researcher Ronnie Langston
Art Director Cherry Barbacena

Join the conversation

6 Best Scar Removal Creams

Thanks for reading my article. I value your feedback and invite you to join the conversation:

  • Share your opinion on the list
  • Suggest an item for consideration
  • Review items you've tried
— Katie Katie Schenk
  • Miranda
    MirandaWell Scar serum of dermalmd is one best scar removal serum I burned myself with a flat iron and I been using this serum for two months and I can see a huge improvement.
  • I suffer from acne that leaves my skin scarred all over, I tried exfoliation and other methods to no avail or with extremely slow/barely noticeable results. I decided to give dermalmd scar serum a try and couldn't be happier, it has really improved my acne scars and removed many of them. I've been using this serum daily and am truly happy with the results over the past few weeks. If I had a before and after shot I would post it, it's totally worth the money. Newer scars tend to fade faster I've noticed, but I have noticed older scars lightening up too.

You May Also Like

See more in Beauty

Never make a dumb purchase again
Our tips in your mailbox:
for access to exclusive free content -- it's easy!
Newsletter signup