8 Best Mascara Reviews

8 Best Mascara Reviews

9
Hours
Researched
51
Products
Evaluated

After 9 hours of research evaluating 51 products, we picked Urban Decay Perversion Mascara as our top choice.

We know the struggle of trying to find the perfect mascara for your lashes. With the hundreds of brands out there - where do you even begin? Mascara should help define, lengthen, volumize, and curl your lashes. We're here to help. 

What to Look For? 

When searching for the best mascara, you're going to want to look at the formula and the brush type. Knowing what is in your mascara is essential - you don't want something that contains a ton of toxins or could irritate your eyes and skin. 

The brush type is going to determine how the formula applies to your lashes. Does the brush bend to give your lashes a pretty curl? Is the brush thin or shaped to cover those hard to reach lashes? 

What Else Sould You Know?

Keep in mind that mascara is the shortest lasting make-up. Remember to replace your mascara every three months to avoid any bacteria growth. Also, be sure to never share your mascara as this can also cause unwanted bacteria. 

Let's Take a Look! 

Below we've compiled a list of our favorite mascaras on the market right now. For more of our favorite make-up essentials be sure to check out our best eyeliners, lipsticks, and under-eye concealers

Why trust us: Faveable has spent thousands of hours researching, interviewing experts, and testing products to come up with carefully selected lists trusted by millions of consumers since 2013.

8 Best Mascara Reviews

  • 8. L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara
  • 7. Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
  • 6. COVERGIRL LashBlast Volume Mascara
  • 5. It's So BIG Volumizing Mascara
  • 4. COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions LashBlast Mascara
  • 3. It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara
  • 2. Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara
  • 1. Urban Decay Perversion Mascara

Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

#8

L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara

Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes: L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara
Brush
8.9
Formula
8.7
Value
8.8
Overall
88%
88 % Editor Score
80 % User Score
57 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Gives a natural, full look to lashes
  • Clump-resistant
  • Great for sensitive eyes

If you wear contacts or typically have very sensitive eyes - check out this mascara. This original volume building mascara glides onto lashes, lengthening and thickening the appearance of your lashes. 

The formula occasionally comes out a little clumpy on the brush. 

Expert Ratings

Brush

8.9 / 10

The volume maximizing brush separates and builds on each lash to create long-lasting full-bodied lashes. 

Simply hold the brush at the base of lashes and slide upwards. Apply multiple times for even thicker, more luscious lashes. 

Formula

8.7 / 10

This formula is made to resist clumping, and help keep lashes soft. No more flakey or crusty lashes! This is a water-based mascara, but you will still need a make-up remover cloth to remove mascara or soap and water. This mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes or contact wearers. 

Value

8.8 / 10

You're getting 0.26oz for $5.55. This is a great cheap mascara that's going to give you a thick, long-lasting, natural look. 

Overall Editor Score

8.8 / 10

Best Natural Mascara

#7

Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara

Best Natural Mascara: Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
Brush
8.9
Formula
9.2
Value
8.9
Overall
90%
90 % Editor Score
82 % User Score
41 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Made from Amazonian clay
  • Helps condition and repair lashes
  • Non-irritating

This Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara is one of the best natural mascaras out there. It helps restore and rebuild your lashes while also adding thickness and volume. 

Apply lightly and softly to avoid clumping, the formula is a little thicker than others. 

Expert Ratings

Brush

8.9 / 10

This brush tends to each lash to create a full, defined look. Apply this product lightly at first - the thicker, softer bristles mean it's going to come on a little heavier than other mascaras. 

Formula

9.2 / 10

This formula is one of a kind. It's made from Amazonian clay and nourishes your lashes while you wear it. The formula hydrates, balances, and repairs lashes to help restore beat up or almost non-existent lashes to fuller, longer, healthier lashes. 

If you've been using mascara with a lot of chemicals and have noticed damage, this is the perfect mascara to switch to. It's going to help bring your lashes back to their natural state, while also acting as a beautiful mascara. This formula also helps prevent lash loss and improves the overall health of your eyelashes. 

Value

8.9 / 10

If you are looking for a mascara that is going to restore your lashes - this is a value that can't be beat. The 0.24oz tube is priced at $23.00 on Amazon, and while we understand this is a little more expensive, the restoring and preventative properties are well worth the price. 

Overall Editor Score

9.0 / 10

Best Drugstore Mascara

#6

COVERGIRL LashBlast Volume Mascara

Best Drugstore Mascara: COVERGIRL LashBlast Volume Mascara
Brush
8.9
Formula
8.8
Value
9.3
Overall
90%
90 % Editor Score
85 % User Score
34 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Builds lashes well
  • Adds real volume
  • Holds all day long

The Covergirl LashBlash Volume Mascara is a classic. It's been around for a long time with good reason.  

The brush is not great at reaching tiny corner lashes. 

Expert Ratings

Brush

8.9 / 10

The bristles on this brush are extremely thin, which helps you add an even coat that you can then build on. The brush glides through lashes and adds natural-looking length and volume. 

Formula

8.8 / 10

This dark black, creamy formula is great for all eye colors. The formula goes on lightly with the first application without clumping and with several applications, this formula builds to a thick, voluminous lash. 

The best way to remove this formula is with makeup remover - warm water alone will not do the trick. 

Value

9.3 / 10

This is probably one of the best values when it comes to mascara - you're getting a 0.44oz tube for only $6.29 on Amazon. It can't be beaten. 

Overall Editor Score

9.0 / 10

Best Volumizing Mascara

#5

It's So BIG Volumizing Mascara

Best Volumizing Mascara: It's So BIG Volumizing Mascara
Brush
8.9
Formula
9.1
Value
9.2
Overall
91%
91 % Editor Score
87 % User Score
40 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Gives a long lasting curl
  • Adds tons of volume
  • No clumping

The "It's So BIG Volumizing Mascara" is going to give your lashes real volume. It's clump free, flake free, and (bonus!) cruelty-free! This mascara doesn't smudge and is waterproof - yet it also washes off easily! 

This mascara is going to work better with medium to longer lashes. If your lashes are very short, or not really there, this mascara is not going to give you length or tons of volume.

Expert Ratings

Brush

8.9 / 10

This corset shaped brush gives an even and precise application. It's perfect for those hard to reach places (you know those annoying corner lashes you can never seem to get!) The brush hugs your lashes from root to end, giving a voluminous look and an everlasting curl thanks to the beeswax formula. 

Formula

9.1 / 10

This formula is water based and exceptionally light - it's not going to weigh down your lashes or feel sticky like other leading brands. The formula is blended with natural Carnauba and beeswax - which helps keep a beautiful curl on your lashes all day long. Thanks to this natural and lightweight formula, the mascara is also very easy to wipe off. 

This formula is also safe to use on lash extensions - hooray! 

Value

9.2 / 10

The tube is 0.64 ounces and costs $13.50. You don't need much to achieve beautiful natural looking lashes - enabling this product to last for a long time. 

Overall Editor Score

9.1 / 10

Best Clump-Free Mascara

#4

COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions LashBlast Mascara

Best Clump-Free Mascara: COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions LashBlast Mascara
Brush
9.0
Formula
9.2
Value
9.3
Overall
92%
92 % Editor Score
90 % User Score
35 Bought

Why People Love it

  • The best clump free mascara
  • Adds volume and length
  • Great price

Covergirl's Clump Crusher Extensions LashBlast Mascara is everything in one. It adds length, volume, and prevents clumping in your lashes. Depending on how much you apply, you can get natural looking long lashes, or magazine-style voluminous lashes. 

Expert Ratings

Brush

9.0 / 10

The brush is curved, which helps lift and elongate your lashes. This brush works to separate lashes while adding volume. Essentially if you've been considering getting lash extensions - try this product first. It's going to give your real lashes all the volume and length you need.  

Hold the brush as close to lashes as possible, start at the roots, and slowly wiggle the brush to the tips for best application. 

Formula

9.2 / 10

The fiber stretch formula sweeps through lashes - preventing clumps and adding volume. 

Value

9.3 / 10

Possibly one of the best values on our list - this 0.44oz Covergirl clump-free mascara sells for $5.50 on Amazon. This is a great mascara to stock up on and use for years to come. 

Overall Editor Score

9.2 / 10

Best Lengthening Mascara

#3

It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara

Best Lengthening Mascara: It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara
Brush
9.3
Formula
9.2
Value
9.3
Overall
93%
93 % Editor Score
92 % User Score
42 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Adds crazy length to lashes
  • Feels smooth and silky
  • Stays on all day

It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara gives your lashes natural looking longevity. The Elastic Stretch Technology wraps each lash creating more defined, longer looking lashes. 

This mascara is not waterproof. 

Expert Ratings

Brush

9.3 / 10

This brush separates and then grabs on to each lash - elongating the appearance of your lashes with just one application. 

Start from the root and gently glide up the lashes to create long looking natural lashes. For a more intense look, apply multiple coats. 

Formula

9.2 / 10

This cruelty-free formula has peptides, proteins, biotin, lash-enhancing polymers, and collagen. You're not going to have flaky lashes thanks to this formula, and it is effortless to wash off. 

Value

9.3 / 10

You're getting a 0.30oz for $14.99 on Amazon. For a quality mascara, this is a great deal. 

Overall Editor Score

9.3 / 10

Best Curling Mascara

#2

Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara

Best Curling Mascara: Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara
Brush
9.5
Formula
9.3
Value
9.2
Overall
93%
93 % Editor Score
95 % User Score
39 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Gives all day curls
  • Lengthens eyelashes
  • Smudgeproof formula

This is the curling wand we've all been looking for - the "Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara" genuinely lifts lashes and provides a super curl that lasts up to 12 hours. 

This mascara is thin - it's not going to give your lashes tons of volume. 

Expert Ratings

Brush

9.5 / 10

This brush is specifically designed to give your lashes that perfect curl you've been looking for. Apply this brush to the roots of your lashes and slowly pull up to the tips. This brush is literally a roller for lashes - it grabs, separates, lifts, and then curls lashes. 

Formula

9.3 / 10

The formula has serine and provitamin B5 meaning it's going to provide great conditioning for your lashes. This setting formula holds for 12 hours - meaning all day curled, luscious lashes! 

Value

9.2 / 10

This 0.30oz tube goes for $25.00 on Amazon. It's a little more expensive than some of our other brushes, but it works and is worth it for the curling, longevity, and long lasting lashes. 

Overall Editor Score

9.3 / 10

Best Waterproof Mascara

#1

Urban Decay Perversion Mascara

Best Waterproof Mascara: Urban Decay Perversion Mascara
Brush
9.5
Formula
9.6
Value
9.2
Overall
94%
94 % Editor Score
97 % User Score
52 Bought

Why People Love it

  • Waterproof
  • Adds ultra volume
  • Naturally lengthens lashes 

Urban Decay's Perversion Mascara creates natural, luscious looking lashes. It's waterproof and will stay on lashes all day long. 

A little pricier than other mascaras on our list. 

Expert Ratings

Brush

9.5 / 10

This brush is incredible - slowly separating each lash to provide defined, full, clump-free, voluminous lashes. 

After one application you'll notice defined natural looking lashes, apply several times for a more dramatic look. 

Formula

9.6 / 10

This creamy formula smoothly coats lashes, creating full-bodied, elongated lashes. The formula contains Hairdensyl, (a blend of proteins and amino acids that are known to stimulate lash growth), honey extract, elastane, and marine collagen. It has no parabens, and the brand Urban Decay is completely cruelty-free - woohoo! 

The Perversion Mascara formula stays on through workouts, tears, even the accidental rubbing of the eye. 

Value

9.2 / 10

Yes, this is one of the priciest mascaras on our list, but we seriously think it's worth it. Get the 0.4oz tube for $24.00 or the 0.13oz for $12.00. 

Overall Editor Score

9.4 / 10

Faveable Ratings: 8 Best Mascara Reviews

8 Best Mascara ReviewsBrush FormulaValueOverall
Urban Decay Perversion Mascara Thumbnail
Best Waterproof Mascara
#1Urban Decay Perversion Mascara
9.5
9.6
9.2
94
Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara Thumbnail
Best Curling Mascara
#2Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara
9.5
9.3
9.2
93
It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara Thumbnail
Best Lengthening Mascara
#3It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara
9.3
9.2
9.3
93
COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions LashBlast Mascara Thumbnail
Best Clump-Free Mascara
#4COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions LashBlast Mascara
9.0
9.2
9.3
92
It's So BIG Volumizing Mascara Thumbnail
Best Volumizing Mascara
#5It's So BIG Volumizing Mascara
8.9
9.1
9.2
91
COVERGIRL LashBlast Volume Mascara Thumbnail
Best Drugstore Mascara
#6COVERGIRL LashBlast Volume Mascara
8.9
8.8
9.3
90
Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara Thumbnail
Best Natural Mascara
#7Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
8.9
9.2
8.9
90
L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara Thumbnail
Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes
#8L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara
8.9
8.7
8.8
88

We value your feedback

What did you think of 8 Best Mascara Reviews?
8 Best Mascara Reviews
4.68 Stars (13 Votes)

Vote to enter our $100 Amazon Gift Card giveaway.

Article Staff

Erika has a passion for writing. She is an avid traveler who loves a good road trip. Iced coffee is what keeps her going throughout the busy days in New York, New York. Currently, Erika writes for several blogs and companies specializing in travel, mental health, nature, and current news/politics.  

Editor Jenna Holtz
Researcher Ronnie Langston
Art Director Cherry Barbacena

Join the conversation

8 Best Mascara Reviews

Thanks for reading my article. I value your feedback and invite you to join the conversation:

  • Share your opinion on the list
  • Suggest an item for consideration
  • Review items you've tried
— Erika Erika Wester

You May Also Like

See more in Women

Never make a dumb purchase again
Our tips in your mailbox:
for access to exclusive free content -- it's easy!
Newsletter signup