6 Best Eyebrow Pencil

6 Best Eyebrow Pencil

6
Hours
Researched
37
Products
Evaluated

After 6 hours of research evaluating 37 products, we picked Brow Wiz by Anastasia Beverly Hills as our top choice.

It's no secret that great looking eyebrows can transform your look from zero to sixty in a flash. The right eyebrow pencil can turn dull, sparse eyebrows into full, defined, eye-stopping brows. Creating the perfect brow takes a little time and patience, but with the right tools, we believe you can create your best looking eyebrow yet.

Tell Me More

Below, we have assembled a list of what we've determined to be the best eyebrow pencils on the market right now. Whether you're looking for fuller brows, more defined brows, or simply natural looking brows - we've got you covered. 

For more makeup beauty tips, be sure to check out our reviews on Best Mascara, Best Lipstick, and Best Setting Sprays

6 Best Eyebrow Pencil

  • 6. Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
  • 5. Ardell Beauty Stroke a Brow Feathering Pen
  • 4. Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define
  • 3. L'ORÉAL Brow Stylist Definer
  • 2. BENEFIT COSMETICS Goof Proof Brow Pencil Easy Shape & Fill
  • 1. Brow Wiz by Anastasia Beverly Hills

Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil

#6

Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil: Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
36 Bought
Application
9.0
Features
9.1
Value
9.0
Overall
90%
90 % Editor Score
80 % User Score

Why People Love it

  • Creates soft, defined eyebrows
  • Gently glides on
  • Stays on all day

The Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil glides onto eyebrows and creates a natural, defined look. The teardrop tip helps you create a precise outline while the spoolie brush enables you to blend and shape the brows. 

The spoolie brush is a little small for most users.

Expert Ratings

Application

9.0 / 10

For this eyebrow brush, you're going to get softly defined eyebrows. First, use the narrow point of the teardrop tip to define the brow. Next, use the base of the teardrop tip to fill in your eyebrow from the brow anchor to the brow arch. Finish off your eyebrows with the spoolie brush for natural blend and definition. 

Features

9.1 / 10

This eyebrow pencil is a soft mechanical pencil with a teardrop tip for accurate precision. The pencil glides on, almost like chalk, and the spoolie brush is soft and blends naturally. 

Value

9.0 / 10

Currently, this eyebrow pencil is on sale for $5.31 on Amazon. 

Overall Editor Score

9.0 / 10

Best Liquid Eyebrow Pencil

#5

Ardell Beauty Stroke a Brow Feathering Pen

Best Liquid Eyebrow Pencil: Ardell Beauty Stroke a Brow Feathering Pen
22 Bought
Application
9.2
Features
9.1
Value
8.9
Overall
91%
91 % Editor Score
82 % User Score

Why People Love it

  • Creates good pigmentation
  • Lasts all day
  • Natural looking brushed brows

The Ardell Beauty Stroke a Brow Feathering Pen creates a natural looking stroke to fill in your eyebrows. Use this pen once in the morning, and you'll have beautiful, full eyebrows all day long. 

Some users experienced issues with the pen drying out. Pro tip: Store this eyebrow pen upside down at all times to prevent it from drying out too quickly.

Expert Ratings

Application

9.2 / 10

This is a liquid eyebrow pencil. Gently apply as it will come on thicker than other pencils if used too heavily. Gently stroke this Ardell Beauty feathering brush onto eyebrows to fill in sparse areas. If you want a 3D look, apply layered strokes over brows. 

Features

9.1 / 10

This eyebrow brush is waterproof and smudge-proof. The feathering brush pen has a precision tip to give you full and defined brows. 

Value

8.9 / 10

It's set at a good value and selling on Amazon right now for $12.94. Make sure to store this eyebrow pencil upside down - it preserves the liquid better and makes for a smoother application! 

Overall Editor Score

9.1 / 10

Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

#4

Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define

Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil: Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define
23 Bought
Application
9.3
Features
9.3
Value
9.2
Overall
93%
93 % Editor Score
85 % User Score

Why People Love it

  • Rich, natural color
  • Perfectly defined brows
  • Available in 12 shades

The "Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define" provides a natural definition with fine precision. Transform your brows with the ultra fine tip and blend for natural transition with the spoolie brush. 

A little pricier than some of the other eyebrow pencils on our list. 

Expert Ratings

Application

9.3 / 10

The colors are luxurious and glide on naturally. This brush is super easy to use thanks to the ultra fine precision tip. To shape your eyebrows, use longer strokes at the base of your brow. To fill in eyebrows, use short, upward strokes that move in the direction of your natural hair growth. The spoolie helps to blend for a more natural looking brow. 

Features

9.3 / 10

This eyebrow pencil has it all. It's a perfect blend of a hard and soft formula that won't smudge, is waterproof, and lasts up until twelve hours! This pencil is available in twelve different shades so you can find a color that perfectly fits your natural brow color.

Value

9.2 / 10

This brow pencil will last all day long. It's a little pricier than some of our other pencils, but we genuinely think it's worth it for waterproof, long-lasting, defined brows. 

Overall Editor Score

9.3 / 10

Best Defining Eyebrow Pencil

#3

L'ORÉAL Brow Stylist Definer

Best Defining Eyebrow Pencil: L'ORÉAL Brow Stylist Definer
27 Bought
Application
9.4
Features
9.3
Value
9.4
Overall
94%
94 % Editor Score
89 % User Score

Why People Love it

  • Ultra-fine defining tip
  • Easy to use
  • Creates natural, full brows

This L'ORÉAL Brow Stylist Definer has a waterproof ultra-fine tip that leaves a rich, natural color and defines eyebrows. 

Some users with more oily skin had issues with this pencil lasting on their eyebrows all day. 

Expert Ratings

Application

9.4 / 10

Precisely shape and define eyebrows with the ultra-fine tip. You can draw in natural looking eyebrow hairs and fill in sparse areas. Outline your brow and then gently feather in light strokes. Use the spoolie brush to define and blend. 

Features

9.3 / 10

You've got a pencil that is waterproof, smudge-proof, has a super fine tip for perfect precision, and comes with a spoolie brush for natural definition and blending. You can also create defined, statement looking brows with this pencil. It's straightforward to use - even for a makeup novice. 

Value

9.4 / 10

This eyebrow pencil is selling for $7.57 on Amazon, which is a bargain of a price. 

Overall Editor Score

9.4 / 10

Best Pencil For Fuller Eyebrows

#2

BENEFIT COSMETICS Goof Proof Brow Pencil Easy Shape & Fill

Best Pencil For Fuller Eyebrows: BENEFIT COSMETICS Goof Proof Brow Pencil Easy Shape & Fill
27 Bought
Application
9.5
Features
9.5
Value
9.4
Overall
95%
95 % Editor Score
92 % User Score

Why People Love it

  • Available in twelve shades
  • Thicker tip for fuller eyebrows
  • Extremely easy to use

The Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil is an easy to use eyebrow filler and shaper. It glides on effortlessly and creates a natural looking finish.

A little pricier than some of the other eyebrow pencils.

Expert Ratings

Application

9.5 / 10

With only a few strokes of the pencil, you can achieve natural full looking brows. The wide part of the pencil is best for shaping and filling your brows by applying a few strokes from the base of your eyebrow to the arch. Use the pointed tip of the pencil to define the outer edges and tip of your brow. Use the spoolie brush for lasting definition and to create a natural blend. 

Features

9.5 / 10

The Goof-Proof Brow Pencil has a custom tip that makes it easy to fill and define brows. The glide on pencil creates a lasting color (up to twelve hours) that is waterproof and smudge-proof. The pencil creates a soft, natural looking finish. 

Value

9.4 / 10

You're getting what you pay for with this pencil - it's well worth it. The eyebrow pencil creates a perfectly natural and full finish. 

Overall Editor Score

9.5 / 10

Best Natural Looking Eyebrow Pencil

#1

Brow Wiz by Anastasia Beverly Hills

Best Natural Looking Eyebrow Pencil: Brow Wiz by Anastasia Beverly Hills
34 Bought
Application
9.7
Features
9.6
Value
9.5
Overall
96%
96 % Editor Score
96 % User Score

Why People Love it

  • Mimics natural looking hair
  • Smudge-proof
  • Fine-point tip

Become an eyebrow expert with the Brow Wiz by Anastasia Beverly Hills. With this eyebrow pencil, you can achieve completely natural, full-looking eyebrows. This product is smudge proof, and the ultra-fine tip gives absolute precision for well-defined brows. 

Users say they go through this pencil very quickly. 

Expert Ratings

Application

9.7 / 10

The recommended way to use this pencil is first to use the spoolie brush to stroke hair upwards, then draw an ultra-thin line along the hairline that follows your natural lower arch. Then use the spoolie brush to brush hair downwards, and repeat the same process on your top arch. After you've defined the top and bottom of your eyebrow, gently blend and fill in the rest of your brow where you see fit using the brush and pen. 

Features

9.6 / 10

The formula is almost wax-like which enables it to mimic natural looking hair. This pencil is available in ten different shades so you can find which color is right for you. The spoolie brush enables you to blend the fine tipped pencil for the perfect, natural brow. 

Value

9.5 / 10

Set at $21.00 on Amazon - you're paying for the quality of this brush. It's not going to let you down. 

Overall Editor Score

9.6 / 10

Faveable Ratings: 6 Best Eyebrow Pencil

6 Best Eyebrow PencilApplicationFeaturesValueOverall
Brow Wiz by Anastasia Beverly Hills Thumbnail
Best Natural Looking Eyebrow Pencil
#1Brow Wiz by Anastasia Beverly Hills
9.7
9.6
9.5
96
BENEFIT COSMETICS Goof Proof Brow Pencil Easy Shape & Fill Thumbnail
Best Pencil For Fuller Eyebrows
#2BENEFIT COSMETICS Goof Proof Brow Pencil Easy Shape & Fill
9.5
9.5
9.4
95
L'ORÉAL Brow Stylist Definer Thumbnail
Best Defining Eyebrow Pencil
#3L'ORÉAL Brow Stylist Definer
9.4
9.3
9.4
94
Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define Thumbnail
Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil
#4Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define
9.3
9.3
9.2
93
Ardell Beauty Stroke a Brow Feathering Pen Thumbnail
Best Liquid Eyebrow Pencil
#5Ardell Beauty Stroke a Brow Feathering Pen
9.2
9.1
8.9
91
Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil Thumbnail
Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil
#6Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
9.0
9.1
9.0
90

We value your feedback

What did you think of 6 Best Eyebrow Pencil?
6 Best Eyebrow Pencil
4.60 Stars (20 Votes)

Vote to enter our $100 Amazon Gift Card giveaway.

Article Staff

Erika has a passion for writing. She is an avid traveler who loves a good road trip. Iced coffee is what keeps her going throughout the busy days in New York, New York. Currently, Erika writes for several blogs and companies specializing in travel, mental health, nature, and current news/politics.  

Editor Jenna Holtz
Researcher Ronnie Langston
Art Director Cherry Barbacena

Join the conversation

6 Best Eyebrow Pencil

Thanks for reading my article. I value your feedback and invite you to join the conversation:

  • Share your opinion on the list
  • Suggest an item for consideration
  • Review items you've tried
— Erika Erika Wester

You May Also Like

See more in Beauty

Never make a dumb purchase again
Our tips in your mailbox:
for access to exclusive free content -- it's easy!
Newsletter signup